Home › Guides

Best Driveway Sealers for Homeowners (DIY)

By the Driveway Done Right team · 6 min read · Updated November 2026

Most driveway sealer looks the same in the pail: black, thick, and smelling like a road crew. On the driveway, though, the difference between a good one and a cheap one shows up fast. Here is what actually matters, and the sealers we would put down ourselves.

Quick picks

What to look for in a driveway sealer

Base material. Almost every DIY sealer you will find today is an asphalt emulsion or an acrylic-modified blend. Coal tar sealers are tougher against gasoline and oil, but they are banned or restricted in several states and many towns because of health and runoff concerns, and they are hard on skin and lungs. For a homeowner, a good asphalt emulsion is the right choice.

"Filler & sealer" with sand or rubber. Products labeled filler and sealer carry fine sand, rubber, or fibers. They fill hairline cracks and surface pores, they hide wear better, and the sand adds grip on a sloped driveway in the rain. Thin, watery sealers look great for one season and then fade.

The year rating. A "10-year" or "8-year" number is a marketing grade, not a promise that you can skip resealing for a decade. In our experience, any driveway with real traffic and Northeast winters wants a fresh coat every two to three years. A higher grade still matters: it means more solids, a thicker film, and better color hold.

Coverage. Expect roughly 250 to 400 square feet per 5-gallon pail per coat, depending on how porous your asphalt is. A standard two-car driveway (about 20 by 40 feet, so 800 square feet) usually needs three to five pails for two coats. Always buy one more than you think, and return what you don't open.

The sealers we recommend

If we had to pick one pail for a typical suburban driveway, this is it. The sand gives the finish real body, so worn spots and small surface cracks disappear, and it does not turn slick when wet. Stir it thoroughly; the solids settle in the bottom of the pail.

A good choice when your driveway was sealed in the last few years and you are keeping it up rather than rescuing it. It goes on smoother than the 10-year grade and dries to an even black.

Black Jack is one of the most common driveway brands in hardware stores, and Drive-Maxx 1000 is its top tier. If you catch it at a good price, it is hard to beat for value. Two thin coats beat one thick one, as with every sealer here.

Ordering two pails at once is convenient, and E-Z Stir lives up to its name: it mixes without a drill paddle. It is a solid middle-of-the-road sealer for a driveway that is not badly worn.

If your driveway is gray, rough, and full of small pits, a resurfacer gives the thick base coat a thin sealer can't. Fix cracks first, then resurface.

When to seal (and when not to)

• Air and ground at 50°F or warmer and rising, for at least 24 hours after you finish.
• No rain in the forecast for 24 to 48 hours.
• New asphalt: wait at least 6 months, ideally a full year, so the oils can cure out.
• Late spring through early fall is the window in most of the country. In the Northeast, that means roughly May through September.

Our bottom line

Buy the best filler-sealer you can afford, fix cracks before you seal, and put it down in two thin coats. The product matters, but the prep matters more. Our step-by-step sealcoating guide walks you through the whole job, and our tools guide covers the squeegees and brushes that make it easier.

Related guides: Oil-based vs. water-based sealer explained · How often should you sealcoat? · Cleaning oil stains before you seal